Skip to main content

Sprinkling – or Immersion?

A dear friend of ours was recently baptized and as a result, Janet and I were reminiscing about our own faith journeys and our thoughts on baptism. We both grew up in the Methodist Church and their method of baptism was by sprinkling. We were both young and neither one of us remembers the occasion of our baptisms at Trinity Methodist Church on the south side of Chicago in Beverly where we grew up. Trinity played a large role in our development and our faith lives.

By the way, we followed the same tradition in our family and all of our children were sprinkled as well when they were quite young, as was the custom in our church. In fact, I would daresay that most people are baptized by sprinkling rather than immersion.

As I learned more about the Bible and went through a number of classes, an interesting topic came up. One of my instructors mentioned that there is no example in the Bible where someone was baptized without first making a profession of faith. In other words, proclaiming that Jesus was Lord and Savior. I never thought about this before and found that it has become a lightning rod issue when it comes to baptism. Clearly, infants, very young children, or even those who may be challenged, don’t or can’t issue a profession of faith prior to baptism. What does that mean for them?

I asked a dear pastor friend of mine about the traditions in the Methodist Church and he pointed me to the story of the Peter and the Roman Centurion. Briefly, Peter, in a vision, was told to visit the house of a Centurion who asked him about Jesus. At first, Peter was somewhat uncomfortable as the soldier wasn’t Jewish and it was not the custom to enter into the homes of Gentiles. It was obvious that God was in the middle of the story and after learning about Jesus, the Scripture tells us that Peter ordered those who heard his message to be baptized.

This lesson occurs in Acts 10 and is quite a great story in case you have never read it. The end result is that Cornelius and his household were baptized. We are told, in Acts 10:47-48, “Then Peter said, “Can anyone keep these people from being baptized with water? They have received the Holy Spirit just as we have.” So he ordered that they be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ.”  The big question is whether Cornelius and his household made a profession of faith first and were then baptized or were there children present as well who were baptized? The Scripture is silent on this point. 

On the other end of the spectrum are those Christians who think that baptism is only for those who have made a clear profession of faith. They site another story in Acts about Philip and the eunuch. In this fascinating story, Philip is stopped by a eunuch and ends up telling him about the good news of Jesus Christ. The eunuch asks to be baptized and the Scripture tells us that Philip performs the baptism where they are. The question here is did the eunuch profess a believe in Jesus as Lord and Savior.

In my own life, I decided to get immersed before I started my seminary training. I was just convicted that is was the right answer for me. Of course, it was post petition of faith. Several years later, as I was teaching our home Bible study, I was referring to the Greek and the baptism of Jesus. In the original language, the Bible makes it clear that Jesus came up out of the water (baptism by immersion) with His eyes wide open looking at heaven.

Most members of our group were sprinkled as children but everyone in our group wanted to be immersed after hearing about the experience of Jesus. Yes, we held a special evening when I baptized every member of our Bible study by immersion. It was a really special evening and was very meaningful to those who had no recollection of their childhood experience. It happened outdoors and each person came up out of the water with their eyes open looking heavenward! It was powerful and we talk about it to this day…

Our verse for tonight is one that you may never have read. That’s because it has been removed from most versions of the Bible. It’s a verse in the story of Philip and the eunuch that occurs in Acts 8. In most accounts of the story, after hearing the good news of Jesus Christ, the eunuch asks if there is any reason he shouldn’t be baptized. And Peter baptizes him… But there is a verse missing.

And that’s our verse for tonight. It can be found in Acts 8:37, more than likely as a footnote unless you are reading a King James Version. It says, “And Philip said, If you believe with all your heart, you may” and the eunuch replied, “I believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God.” In other words, Philip would not baptize the eunuch before there was a profession of faith. Philip gave the eunuch the condition to be baptized and the eunuch issued his confession.

So there you have it – two different accounts of baptism in the Bible. This side of heaven we won’t know which one, or both, are correct in the eyes of God. And each of us, as mature Christians, must decide which path we wish to follow. There are other deeper considerations regarding baptism as well. Does it impart salvation or is it an outward sign of something that has already occurred in your heart? But that’s for another time!

My encouragement this evening is that we should each consider the stories of Cornelius the Centurion and Philip with the eunuch. They are both compelling events in the Scripture and I think we owe it to ourselves to become more familiar with these two wonderful accounts of baptism. My prayer is that, regardless of your Christian belief, the Holy Spirit will be with each of us throughout all eternity and we will dwell with God forever. Have a great day in the Lord, grace and peace…

Leave a Reply